可能一个冰冷/极度寒冷的小行星或彗星罢工和冷却地球吗?- 江南体育网页版- - - - -地球科学堆江南电子竞技平台栈交换 最近30从www.hoelymoley.com 2023 - 07 - 10 - t20:56:03z //www.hoelymoley.com/feeds/question/20157 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/rdf //www.hoelymoley.com/q/20157 10 可能一个冰冷/极度寒冷的小行星或彗星罢工和冷却地球吗? y涌 //www.hoelymoley.com/users/3241 2020 - 09 - 03 - t08:38:56z 2020 - 09 - 07 - t11:54:35z < p >这显然是一个假想的问题,但这似乎是可计算的(我没有这样做,不幸的是数学能力)。注:我没有深入了解彗星小行星/流星/甚至任何空间对象,所以请纠正我如果我犯了任何错误。同时,请回答这个问题考虑地球的当前状态,而不是一个地球过热。< / p > < p >一些命题:< / p > < ol > <李>小行星或彗星是相当大的,寒冷的核心,和由材料热容高李< / > < >李小行星或彗星“strikes"李地球低速< / > <李>小行星或彗星撞击海洋< /李> < / ol > < p >相关:< a href = " https://astronomy.stackexchange.com/questions/8707/how-gently-could-a-comet-asteroid-meteorite-hit-earth " >轻轻如何彗星/小行星陨石“打击”地球? < / > < / p > //www.hoelymoley.com/questions/20157/-/20158 # 20158 13 gerrit回答的可以一个冰冷/极度寒冷的小行星或彗星罢工和冷却地球吗? gerrit //www.hoelymoley.com/users/6 2020 - 09 - 03 - t09:23:20z 2020 - 09 - 03 - t14:08:04z < p >没有,这是不可能的冷却与小行星撞击地球。< / p > < p >任何可能撞击地球的小行星的质量太小了是一个散热器。< a href = " https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicxulub_impactor " rel = " noreferrer " >小行星,杀死了恐龙< / >有一个大规模的<跨类= " math-container " > 10美元^ {16}$ < / span >公斤。地球的质量是< span class = " math-container " > 10美元^ {24}< / span >公斤,美元或1亿倍。无论多冷小行星,释放的动能在影响将很大程度上转化成热量。< / p > //www.hoelymoley.com/questions/20157/-/20159 # 20159 5 弗雷德回答的可以一个冰冷/极度寒冷的小行星或彗星罢工和冷却地球吗? 弗雷德 //www.hoelymoley.com/users/2470 2020 - 09 - 03 - t09:25:25z 2020 - 09 - 03 - t09:25:25z < p >一个小行星或彗星,不。< / p > < p >即使它巨大的你可能会是一个行星灭绝事件像陨石撞到尤卡坦半岛地区导致恐龙灭绝。这是由于大量的灰尘和土壤等,被扔到大气中。< / p > < p >的另一件事,因为小行星或彗星/流星进入地球大气层会立即开始由于与空气摩擦升温。一些小行星将在这个过程中失去了。< / p > < p >如果小行星的< / p > < blockquote > < p >材料热容高< / p > < /引用> < p >可以保护它免受升温而进入大气层之后同样的材料,作为一个优秀的热绝缘体,防止寒冷的核心小行星很快被释放。所以没有即时冷却。< / p > < p >如果小行星撞击海洋,水热能力高。它不会迅速冻结,因为一个潜在的非常大的超级冷岩石还是坠入了大海。会有一些短期局部冷却将恢复很快失去了温度。

If an entire blizzard load of super cold rocks hit the Earth at the same time, the Earth's problem won't be with dealing with any cold it will be in dealing with all the dust raised into the atmosphere and the seismic shocks created by the rocks impacting the ground.

//www.hoelymoley.com/questions/20157/-/20160 # 20160 22 回答大卫Hammen可能冰冷/极度寒冷的小行星或彗星罢工和冷却地球吗? 大卫Hammen //www.hoelymoley.com/users/239 2020 - 09 - 03 - t09:33:53z 2020 - 09 - 03 - t09:33:53z < blockquote > < p >可以一个冰冷/极度寒冷的小行星或彗星罢工和冷却地球吗?< / p > < /引用> < p >。< / p > < p >尽可能最小的速度约11公里/秒的速度,这将需要一个奇迹。为了实现这一目标,对象会进入地球附近通过一个很小的锁眼来观察太阳-地球L1和L2点附近与一个非常小的速度(一颗彗星将不会有非常小的速度),然后近发射地捕捉到月球,然后下降到地球。一颗彗星将更有可能撞击地球40公里/秒,或更大。< / p > < p >,这意味着不管多冷或多热对象之前的影响。动能的影响将矮无论热能对象影响之前。< / p > //www.hoelymoley.com/questions/20157/-/20161 # 20161 21 让-玛丽•Prival回答的可能一个冰冷/极端寒冷的小行星或彗星罢工和冷却地球吗? 让-玛丽•Prival //www.hoelymoley.com/users/18081 2020 - 09 - 03 - t12:01:36z 2020 - 09 - 03 - t12:01:36z < p >我要逆风航行,说“yes"间接< em > < / em >。< / p > < p >虽然你不需要一个寒冷的小行星,一个“正常”;一个就足够了。惊人的地球时,小行星喷射大量的尘埃进入大气层,阻止太阳辐射,从而使地球冷却。这种现象被称为< a href = " https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impact_winter " rel = " noreferrer " >影响冬季< / >和类似于火山和核冬天。< / p > //www.hoelymoley.com/questions/20157/-/20165 # 20165 4 回答在割草机的男人可以一个冰冷/极度寒冷的小行星或彗星罢工和冷却地球吗? 割草机的男人 //www.hoelymoley.com/users/21024 2020 - 09 - 03 - t20:38:24z 2020 - 09 - 03 - t20:38:24z <标题>热动力没有< / h1 > < p >给了一个好的答案骂气溶胶的影响。其他人观察到影响地球补充能量。我只是想看看能源预算。< / p > < p >太阳转储的< a href = " https://phys.org/news/2011-10-vast-amounts-solar-energy-earth.html " rel = " nofollow noreferrer " > < / > 173兆瓦,没完没了。现在,小行星有一个< a href = " https://www.lpi.usra.edu/meetings/lpsc2012/pdf/2626.pdf " rel = " nofollow noreferrer " >热容的< / > < span class = " math-container " > 10美元^ {18}- 10 ^ {24}J / K < / span >美元,根据大小。注意petawatt是< span class = " math-container”> 10美元^ {15}J / s $ < / span >。还要注意,太阳转储<跨类= " math-container " > 10美元^ {18}W美元< / span >地球上每5.8秒左右。< / p > < p >现在,让我们假设我们发现小行星星际空间漂浮在一个寒冷的3 K(或冷或暖……确切的数字并不重要)。让我们进一步假设我们可以在地球和查克土地没有任何重大的能源(我们使用一个外星人拖拉机梁轻轻低表面)。This asteroid will "cool" the earth by heating itself up. So...how much cooling should we expect?

Instead of pretending that the earth is a lone ice box floating in space, and calculating what happens when we drop a large ice cube into it, I think it's more useful to simply ask: "How quickly will the sun melt our ice cube?"

The sun will contribute enough energy to warm the asteroid by 1 K every 6s or so, for a small asteroid. To raise the asteroid from 3 K to earth mean surface temperature of 288 K will take somewhat less than 1800 s, or about 30 minutes. That's about how long an ice cube would last in a chilled beverage on a not particularly warm day.

Now, that is roughly equivalent to turning off the sun for 30 minutes. That would have a noticeable effect on global weather, but I doubt it would remain noticeable even a few days after. Over the course of a year, this blip would amount to a solar energy reduction of 0.005%. Hardly enough to detect in the climate record.

Of course, we picked the smallest asteroid for the initial calculation. If you go towards the large end, you can crank up all these numbers by a factor of a million, more or less. Ceres, for instance, would suck up about 5000% of the sun's annual energy sent to earth. That's 50 years of solar energy, and obviously a significant impact. Given that it's round, we can debate whether Ceres counts as an "asteroid" or not. Nysa is more "asteroid-shaped", but only has about 100x the heat capacity of our initial calculations. So, a solar dip of 0.5% over the course of a year might be enough to notice, but likely not enough to cause attributable long-term climate effects (given that the Milankovitch cycles produce larger variance).

Note that if you start with a more typical asteroid temperature of about 200 K, you would reduce all the energy budget numbers to about 1/3 of their value (meaning, the smallest ice cube would melt in ~10 minutes).

//www.hoelymoley.com/questions/20157/-/20166 # 20166 12 user3067860回答的可以一个冰冷/极度寒冷的小行星或彗星罢工和冷却地球吗? user3067860 //www.hoelymoley.com/users/13310 2020 - 09 - 03 - t21:21:29z 2020 - 09 - 07 - t11:54:35z < p >为你的目的在整个系统(能量)不管这颗小行星轻轻土地或不是因为能量是守恒的:如果小行星放缓通过某种大气制动能量以热量进入大气中。如果它减缓了通过运行到海洋中全速地能量以热量进入海洋。如果能源进入小行星,但它提高了温度高于大气温度,这颗小行星将会额外的热量辐射到大气中随着时间的推移。< / p > < p >假设小行星开始冷可以得到,0 k,全球平均温度是285 k。We will leave the material as a question mark for now, but call the specific heat capacity c. The energy that our asteroid can absorb before it becomes warmer than the average atmospheric temperature is (in Joules):

$$m \cdot \Delta t \cdot c = m\, \mathrm{kg} \cdot 285\, \mathrm{K} \cdot c\,\mathrm{J}\,\mathrm{kg}^{-1}\mathrm{K}^{-1}$$

Since the escape velocity of Earth is 11 km/s (11000 m/s) the total energy coming in (in kg m^2/s^2 aka Joules) will be:

$$\frac{1}{2}mv^2 = \frac{1}{2} m \mathrm{kg} \cdot 11000^2 \,\mathrm{m^2}\mathrm{s^{-2}}$$

We want our asteroid to be capable of absorbing more energy than the energy it has from falling:

$$m \mathrm{kg} \cdot 285 \mathrm{K} \cdot c\mathrm{J}\,\mathrm{kg}^{-1}\mathrm{K}^{-1} > \frac{1}{2} m \mathrm{kg} \cdot 11000^2 \,\mathrm{m^2}\mathrm{s^{-2}}$$

Mass cancels out immediately and after some arithmetic, we end up with (rounding quite a bit) c > 200,000 J/kg K.

Unfortunately, the material with the highest specific heat is hydrogen, with a specific heat of about 14,000 J/kg K, which is nowhere near what we need.

Short answer: No.

//www.hoelymoley.com/questions/20157/-/20167 # 20167 0 LazyReader回答的可以一个冰冷/极度寒冷的小行星或彗星罢工和冷却地球吗? LazyReader //www.hoelymoley.com/users/21028 2020 - 09 - 04 - t03:32:02z 2020 - 09 - 04 - t03:32:02z < p >当彗星冷他们消失在空间接近太阳和地球。在与大气接触他们烧掉。如果彗星是足够大的火球他们可能拥有相同的气候问题白垩纪小行星撞击< / p > //www.hoelymoley.com/questions/20157/-/20173 # 20173 1 舍伍德博茨回答的可以一个冰冷/极度寒冷的小行星或彗星罢工和冷却地球吗? 舍伍德博茨 //www.hoelymoley.com/users/13145 2020 - 09 - 06 - t04:30:01z 2020 - 09 - 06 - t04:30:01z < p >影响通常发生在20到70 km / s。< / p > < p >让我们看看20公里/秒。< / p > < p > 1公斤的质量在20公里/秒= 1公斤* 20000 m / s * 20000 m / s / 2 = 2亿焦耳。< / p > < p >把冰从绝对零度熔点需要1000 * 273 * 0.5 = 13.6万焦耳。是的,融化需要能源,因此将汽化,但这是非常小的土豆比动能。(水冰是最大的彗星冰的一部分。氨有稍高比热、甲烷、低得多)。< / p > < p >漠然的来源,一颗彗星并不影响率。< / p > <人力资源/ > < p >让我们相反,邀请Archanangel Gabriel下来,轻轻的躺彗星融化,冷却面积。< / p > < p >大彗星20公里直径。假设固体冰为了简单起见。20公里范围是4/3 *π* 10 ^ 3 = 4200立方公里的冰。< / p > < p >哇。给我马提尼很多冰块!

Comparison: Canada has an area of 10 million km2. If you had 1/10 of a meter of ice (4 inches...) you would have 1/10,000 of a km * 10 million km = 1000 km3. So your comet has about the four times the chilling effect as spring in Canada. (Ok, 10 cm is arbitrary.)

Or the same as 40 cm of ice on Canada.

Now a square meter with 40 cm of ice would be about 400 kg. (Please, do NOT muddle the waters with the different density of water and ice. This is a BOTE calc.)

1 kg of ice takes about 500 kJ to melt, assuming it's starting from close to absolute zero. 400 kg takes 200,000 kJ

Solar constant is about 1 kW/m2 at noon. (Yes this is variable depending on latitude, time of year, cloud cover, and things that otherwise were thought only to affect the flavour of pizza) So 200,000 seconds of noonday sun would melt the ice. About 55 hours.

Which would be about 200 hours due to night, and low angles. 8 days. Ish.

However Canada isn't the whole world. Only about 1/50 of it. so 8/50 or about 4 hours sunlight over the earth to melt the comet.

Like throwing an ice cube from your drink into a campfire.


You're left with nuclear winter possibilities. Others have addressed that.

Baidu
map