为什么地球的年龄由约会陨石而不是自己的石头?- 江南体育网页版- - - - -地球科学堆江南电子竞技平台栈交换 最近30从www.hoelymoley.com 2023 - 08 - 25 - t07:53:50z //www.hoelymoley.com/feeds/question/2830 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/rdf //www.hoelymoley.com/q/2830 36 为什么地球的年龄由约会陨石而不是自己的石头? 希拉克 //www.hoelymoley.com/users/1138 2014 - 11 - 18 - t12:04:32z 2022 - 05 - 03 - t03:58:00z < p >阅读课程在前寒武纪,我读到:< / p > < blockquote > < p >地球时代(约45亿年)日期由于陨石撞击地球在其形成而不是地球内部材料组成。< / p > < /引用> < p >岂不是更准确的通过其内部材料吗?为什么我们使用如果他们的陨石撞击地球形成后吗? < / p > //www.hoelymoley.com/questions/2830/-/2831 # 2831 39 由Gimelist回答为什么地球的年龄由约会陨石而不是自己的石头? Gimelist //www.hoelymoley.com/users/725 2014 - 11 - 18 - t12:17:09z 2014 - 11 - 19 - t12:46:56z < p > < >强一些背景:< /强> < / p > < p >我们能确定特定的岩石和矿物的年龄使用的放射性测量和某些元素的放射性同位素。最常见的是U-Th-Pb, Rb-Sr Sm-Nd。简单地说,由此产生的日期已经过去的时间从矿物的结晶。显然有复杂性,但是没有这个答案的关键。< br > < br > < / p > < blockquote > < p >为什么我们使用如果他们的陨石撞击地球形成后吗?< / p > < /引用> < p > <强>简短回答< /强>:因为陨石形成的地球和太阳系的其他部分。< / p > < p > < >强长回答< /强>:地球形成连同其他太阳系及其陨石大约45亿年前。当陨石落在地球上,你把它们捡起来,你可以约会的时间形成。< / p > < p >你说:< / p > < blockquote > < p >为什么我们使用如果他们的陨石撞击地球形成后吗?< / p > < /引用> < p >你必须区分陨石形成的时间和时间,它们撞击地球。 If I throw a meteorite at you, and you date it, it still records the formation time and not the time that I threw it at you. Hitting the Earth does not reset the radioactive clock in the meteorite's minerals.

Wouldn't it be more accurate by doing it with its inner materials?

It would. There are two problems:

  • We don't have materials from the time of Earth's formation. The Earth is a dynamic place, and rocks are getting formed and destroyed all the time (also see related question). It may be that such old rocks exist on Earth, but because they are so old there are either metamorphosed and buried deep in the Earth or covered by sedimentary rocks. The oldest exposed rock on Earth available for study is the 4 billion year Acasta Gneiss in Canada. The oldest mineral on Earth is a zircon found in Australia, which is 4.4 billion years old. These are the only two materials that are known to be older than 4 billion years on Earth. There could be more, but we just couldn't find them.
  • The moon forming event occurred some tens of million of years after the formation of the Earth. This event destroyed the Earth's crust and any evidence of the age of the Earth, on Earth itself.

This is why meteorites are excellent for this task - they mostly formed during the formation of the Solar System.

//www.hoelymoley.com/questions/2830/-/2834 # 2834 6 由user3541786回答为什么地球的年龄由约会陨石而不是自己的石头? user3541786 //www.hoelymoley.com/users/1154 2014 - 11 - 18 - t18:28:47z 2014 - 11 - 18 - t18:28:47z < p >很简单,看到陨石与地球形成,然而,从这个星球上几乎是一个熔汤你不能正确日期,因为我们只能日期后它冷却下来。意味着陨石持有一个更准确的时间框架,因为他们没有融化形成我们的外壳!这意味着他们的日期(我使用术语松散)是正确的。< / p > < p >换句话说陨石与地球形成只是决定冷静下来并没有完全融化的备件。虽然大多数我们的漂亮的岩石形成后不少地球被因为它们冷却汤地壳形成我们亲爱的。< / p > < blockquote > < p >岂不是更准确的通过其内部材料吗?< / p > < /引用> < p >对铀你想去游泳吗?没有真的,很难获得老,古老的岩石和矿物。最好的办法是分析陨石。< / p > //www.hoelymoley.com/questions/2830/-/2839 # 2839 19 答案由罗兰Pechtel给出的原因是地球的年龄测定岩石的陨石,而不是自己的? 罗兰Pechtel //www.hoelymoley.com/users/1160 2014 - 11 - 18 - t20:55:12z 2014 - 11 - 18 - t20:55:12z < p >的答案是正确的但他们忽略的基本问题提供解释<强> < /强>为什么他们是正确的:< / p > < p >当你约会一个摇滚你得到它凝固,不是点材料。地球上最岩石融化后一次又一次,因此对于如何是无用的旧地球。< / p > //www.hoelymoley.com/questions/2830/-/23774 # 23774 1 由Markoul11回答为什么地球的年龄由约会陨石而不是自己的石头? Markoul11 //www.hoelymoley.com/users/26772 2022 - 04 - 26 - t17:55:32z 2022 - 04 - 26 - t17:55:32z < p > < a href = " https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clair_Cameron_Patterson " rel = " nofollow noreferrer " >帕特森< / >不能从铀铅衰变根时代地球因为锆石样本污染< a href = " https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clair_Cameron_Patterson # Measurement_of_age_of_Earth”rel = " nofollow noreferrer " > < / >铅污染。所以他使用陨石假设他们在大约同一时期形成的,因此地球45.5亿年前。< / p >
Baidu
map